When it comes to swimming pool, both concrete and vinyl pools are the popular options. Each style has numerous benefits and some flaws. The decision finally rests on your personal preferences, type of backyard you have, and your budget. Here is an honest comparison of vinyl and concrete pools to make things easier for you.
Time for Installation
The installation of a swimming pool, time is of the essence. You want your pool to be ready before the next season. If you opt for a concrete pool, you may have to wait for 3-6 months for its completion. Your pool won’t be ready for the season if you start late or postpone its construction. On the other hand, vinyl pools do not take more than 4-8 weeks for complete installation. Even if you start construction a little late, you can spend a major part of the summer by swimming in your pool.
In the building of a swimming pool, the cost is the most important factor. Depending on your budget, you can choose the best type of pool for your home. It is expensive to build a concrete pool while vinyl liner pools have a much lower initial cost. In addition to upfront cost, pool ownership also involves the lifetime cost of maintenance.
Concrete pools have a higher cost of maintaining, thanks to replastering, acid washes, electricity, and chemicals needed to keep it in shape. In the case of vinyl pools, the cost of maintenance is lower than concrete pools by a significant margin. A vinyl pool needs less electricity and chemicals for its regular upkeep.
Interior Surface Finish
Concrete pools have rough interiors that can scrape your skin. You need to wear water shoes to protect your feet from blisters and soreness caused by uneven surfaces. There are surface finishes like plaster to give them a smooth feel.
You can also choose polished finishes, glass tiles, or natural stone finishes that enhance their interior surface texture. The vinyl liner pools, on the other hand, are smooth except on the ridges where one part of the liner meets another. It hardly causes any scrapes or blisters on your skin.
When it comes to durability, concrete is incredibly strong. It comes with a robust plaster finish as well. The interiors cannot be damaged by sharp objects or tools. But, you need to replaster the pool and replace the waterline tiles every 10-15 years. Vinyl pools lag behind on this front.
They are easy to install but they do not have the durability of concrete pools. Even the thick vinyl liners need replacement after 5-9 years. The metal wall panels used in installation can corrode while polymer panels become brittle with time. So, concrete can survive much more than vinyl pools.
Algae infestation is a big problem for pool owners. When selecting the best pool type, you can’t ignore the need to protect your investment against algae. The plaster finish of a concrete pool is porous and attracts unwanted algae. The surface of the vinyl liner pool is lesser porous. Hence, it restricts algae growth except in submerged areas with restricted water circulation.
This is a comprehensive comparison of concrete and vinyl pools.